StrategyDesk can handle the SRS Swing #2 with no problem.
The scaling out in Swing #1 is more of a problem. One
possibility would be to run 3 strategies: one for each of the
scaleout percentages, but this would mean paying 3 times the
commissions. What I did was to only program the stop loss and
reversal parts of the strategy, and then to manually sell when the
scaleout targets were reached, adjusting the exit sells to the
remaining shares (using Edit>No reset for the strategies).
This requires calculating the targets, tracking the price, and
editing the amounts, which is certainly not an automatic
system. Therefore I think that I will only be running the #2
system for this reason. I have to note that the manual mode
worked in my favor once, since the price exceeded the target by the
time that I got to sell, so I put in a trailing stop loss order and
made some extra profit. Hope this helps.
I am seeing them on several charts (SRS, SKF) in TD Ameritrade's
Command Center, but if I "re-plot" them, the spikes
disappear. And I have a limit order above them that never got
filled. But they sure look real when they show up, complete
with a price. Thanks.
Recently there was discussion about whether to turn off the
mechanical systems on "Fed" days - my take on it was that it didn't
make much difference in overall results. Does anyone has a
similar analysis for Options Expiration days?
So what is the best plan when it re-opens? Do these events
usually get sold off on the (presumed) gap up? Or should I
put on a trailing stop, maybe on 1/2 position to ride any spike
up? Any experience on this? (Mine has only been in the
opposite direction
.
It looks like the value could be almost zero for quite a while
after a reversal, which makes sense. So I would think that
moving below +50 would be a possible signal of the start of a
reversal. If you wait to get to -50, you might miss most of a
move down IMHO.
This won't wait for the price to reach the BP before
buying. Since the limit is highest price you are willing to
pay, if the current price is less than that, it will buy right
away. I use TDAmeritrade's Trade Triggers, which allow you to
enter a trigger point (of various types) which will then submit an
order (market or limit). Hope this helps.
I'm using StrategyDesk and have different results. Mine
(and others') triggered long at 12:30 and mine has not
reversed. Are you sure that your formulas/trading hours/etc
are correct?
Just a heads-up to anyone coding the Weighted Moving Average
mechanical system in StrategyDesk: The WMA function is under
the "Moving Average" function. The formula just replaces MA
(used for the simple MA) by WMA, so the formula will start as:
If you click on "Recent" next to "View All", you get the
messages in order (like the old blog). Then you can read all
the replies/posts since the last time you checked.
Apparently my post with formulas was deleted even though I
didn't include the moving average parameters. But anyway, as
promised, here is the way that you add a stop loss to an Exit
formula. For example, for a hypothetical 2% stop loss, you
would add to your formula:
OR (Bar[Close,1] <= EntryPrice * 0.98)
This checks the price each minute and, I hope, minimizes the
chance of a wild point from inadvertently triggering the exit.
The only problems other than programming bugs that I had were
that I have had 2 unexpected trades occur. The first one sold
a position in a swing trade strategy with no crossover. The
formula did include a profit stop which wasn't even close to being
hit, so I attributed it to a bad data point that triggered it
(wasn't able to confirm). I added a "filter" to the formula
and didn't see it occur again, but have stopped that strategy.
The second one occurred yesterday morning and seemed to be
related to the MAs running very close together at the end of the
preceding day. I had a buy and sell of FAS within seconds of
each other right at the open, which shouldn't happen. This
then allowed the FAZ strategy to trigger, which shouldn't
have. I still have to call them about this.
Yes, I had the same cross yesterday at 3:15. It looks to
me that there was a weird, inadvertent trigger on StrategyDesk to
buy FAS at the opening today based on the very close MAs, and this
allowed the FAZ buy to occur at 9:45; otherwise it would have still
been on the "same side" of the cross and not triggered. It
may be that different platforms had different results, since the
MAs were running so close.
Bob
Newsletter
Subscribe to our email list for regular free market updates
as well as a chance to get coupons!
The community is delayed by three days for non registered users.
Title: Strategy Desk for Swing
Swing SRS and TD Ameritrade
Posted by twins on 26th of Sep 2009 at 10:52 pm
StrategyDesk can handle the SRS Swing #2 with no problem. The scaling out in Swing #1 is more of a problem. One possibility would be to run 3 strategies: one for each of the scaleout percentages, but this would mean paying 3 times the commissions. What I did was to only program the stop loss and reversal parts of the strategy, and then to manually sell when the scaleout targets were reached, adjusting the exit sells to the remaining shares (using Edit>No reset for the strategies). This requires calculating the targets, tracking the price, and editing the amounts, which is certainly not an automatic system. Therefore I think that I will only be running the #2 system for this reason. I have to note that the manual mode worked in my favor once, since the price exceeded the target by the time that I got to sell, so I put in a trailing stop loss order and made some extra profit. Hope this helps.
Bob in NJ
Title: UGA Taxes I have traded
UGA- tax implications
Posted by twins on 23rd of Sep 2009 at 11:52 am
I have traded UGA in my IRA without any problem. What kind of tax implication were you thinking about? I can't imagine any.
Bob
Title: Candle wick I got one
Ninja Trader bad cande wick
Posted by twins on 21st of Sep 2009 at 10:38 am
I got one on Ameritrade on SRS and reset it by just changing the time scale on the chart from 3 days to 2 days. Worth a try.
Data spikes
FAS Spikes
Posted by twins on 16th of Sep 2009 at 01:10 pm
I am seeing them on several charts (SRS, SKF) in TD Ameritrade's Command Center, but if I "re-plot" them, the spikes disappear. And I have a limit order above them that never got filled. But they sure look real when they show up, complete with a price. Thanks.
FAS Spikes
Posted by twins on 16th of Sep 2009 at 12:58 pm
Does anyone know why the FAS chart is showing many spikes down in the last half-hour? They appear to be momentary trades at about $83-$84. Thanks.
Bob
TD Ameritrade
Can you log on TDAmeritrade???
Posted by twins on 14th of Sep 2009 at 09:48 am
No, I was on TD Ameritrade and got kicked off and can't log back in again.
Update: I just was allowed in again.
Or "Buy the mystery, sell
Posted by twins on 9th of Sep 2009 at 02:49 pm
Or "Buy the mystery, sell the history."
Options Exp vs Systems
Posted by twins on 20th of Aug 2009 at 12:51 pm
Recently there was discussion about whether to turn off the mechanical systems on "Fed" days - my take on it was that it didn't make much difference in overall results. Does anyone has a similar analysis for Options Expiration days?
Bob in NJ
iphone
Cant get charts on iphone now...
Posted by twins on 14th of Aug 2009 at 02:54 pm
Press and hold on the thumbnail chart for about 2 seconds. A menu will pop up at the bottom. Choose "Open in New Page" and you'll get it.
Bob in NJ
Looks like it re-opened at
King Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NYSE: KG) Embeda Painkiller Approved by FDA - Bloomberg.
Posted by twins on 13th of Aug 2009 at 04:14 pm
Looks like it re-opened at 4:05. I show a last trade of 11.00, but not much activity from what I can tell. Hopefully tomorrow?
Title: KG Action Plan So what
King Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NYSE: KG) Embeda Painkiller Approved by FDA - Bloomberg.
Posted by twins on 13th of Aug 2009 at 03:42 pm
So what is the best plan when it re-opens? Do these events usually get sold off on the (presumed) gap up? Or should I put on a trailing stop, maybe on 1/2 position to ride any spike up? Any experience on this? (Mine has only been in the opposite direction .
Bob
NYHL
NYHL
Posted by twins on 6th of Aug 2009 at 09:01 pm
It looks like the value could be almost zero for quite a while after a reversal, which makes sense. So I would think that moving below +50 would be a possible signal of the start of a reversal. If you wait to get to -50, you might miss most of a move down IMHO.
Bob
Title: BP as limit for
Entries for Watch List breakouts
Posted by twins on 29th of Jul 2009 at 12:30 pm
This won't wait for the price to reach the BP before buying. Since the limit is highest price you are willing to pay, if the current price is less than that, it will buy right away. I use TDAmeritrade's Trade Triggers, which allow you to enter a trigger point (of various types) which will then submit an order (market or limit). Hope this helps.
New SRS system
New SRS system
Posted by twins on 28th of Jul 2009 at 03:26 pm
That's what I got. Also using SD.
SRS 15min
did SRS 15min cross? thx
Posted by twins on 28th of Jul 2009 at 01:26 pm
I'm using StrategyDesk and have different results. Mine (and others') triggered long at 12:30 and mine has not reversed. Are you sure that your formulas/trading hours/etc are correct?
Title: StrategyDesk WMA Just a heads-up
Posted by twins on 27th of Jul 2009 at 10:33 pm
Just a heads-up to anyone coding the Weighted Moving Average mechanical system in StrategyDesk: The WMA function is under the "Moving Average" function. The formula just replaces MA (used for the simple MA) by WMA, so the formula will start as:
MovingAverage[WMA, ...
Bob in NJ
If you click on "Recent"
New Blog
Posted by twins on 27th of Jul 2009 at 09:18 am
If you click on "Recent" next to "View All", you get the messages in order (like the old blog). Then you can read all the replies/posts since the last time you checked.
Title: Stop Loss for SD Apparently
Posted by twins on 23rd of Jul 2009 at 02:45 pm
Apparently my post with formulas was deleted even though I didn't include the moving average parameters. But anyway, as promised, here is the way that you add a stop loss to an Exit formula. For example, for a hypothetical 2% stop loss, you would add to your formula:
OR (Bar[Close,1] <= EntryPrice * 0.98)
This checks the price each minute and, I hope, minimizes the chance of a wild point from inadvertently triggering the exit.
Hope this helps.
Bob in NJ
Title: Strategy Desk glitches The only
Posted by twins on 23rd of Jul 2009 at 09:05 am
The only problems other than programming bugs that I had were that I have had 2 unexpected trades occur. The first one sold a position in a swing trade strategy with no crossover. The formula did include a profit stop which wasn't even close to being hit, so I attributed it to a bad data point that triggered it (wasn't able to confirm). I added a "filter" to the formula and didn't see it occur again, but have stopped that strategy.
The second one occurred yesterday morning and seemed to be related to the MAs running very close together at the end of the preceding day. I had a buy and sell of FAS within seconds of each other right at the open, which shouldn't happen. This then allowed the FAZ strategy to trigger, which shouldn't have. I still have to call them about this.
Hope this helps.
Bob in NJ
Title: FAZ Mech Sys Yes, I
Posted by twins on 22nd of Jul 2009 at 11:09 am
Yes, I had the same cross yesterday at 3:15. It looks to me that there was a weird, inadvertent trigger on StrategyDesk to buy FAS at the opening today based on the very close MAs, and this allowed the FAZ buy to occur at 9:45; otherwise it would have still been on the "same side" of the cross and not triggered. It may be that different platforms had different results, since the MAs were running so close.
Bob