Posted by bulf6285 on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 01:37 pm
Brophy, I used Advanced Get for years when I was trading on the
floor of the Comex. The MOBs were incredibly accurate. Their Elliot
Wave count was also pretty good. Never been able to replicate the
MOB in Tradestation, and I have tried very hard :) Can't find a
good enough explanation of the indicator to work off of though. I'd
be happy to do the programming and share if anyone has the
parameters.
Yes, I've used Advanced Get from time to time over the years.
Creator was Tom Joseph who has created many excellent indicators.
(He has his own company now and most recently created many of the
same tools for VectorVest programs. I mean almost exactly the same
tools and calls them different names! ha!!) The best explanation of
it that I heard was a combination of a Fib extension and Gann.
However, his Advanced Get's Elliot Wave left me cold though. Have
no idea how you would recreate it. If you purchased it, then you
own it forever and you can use any number of charting services.
there's versions on Trading View on Elliot Wave indicators like
that, one of them I have is called Elliot Wave Absolute, it's okay,
But I don't use it to make decisions, more just fun to look at once
in a while
but guys, view them out of curiosity, I won't put too much
energy into them. Focus on price action, patterns, and a few
indicators that you might use.
the guys who are always looking for that next holy grail
indicator never settle on something and master it, and thus end up
never making any money.
plus if you think about - there's nothing magical about those
programs trying to generate EW signals. They use technical
indicators to try and have it guess what the pattern is - which
will never ever be as good as you doing it yourself. It's just like
those programs that try to identify stock patterns like coils,
flags, inverse H&S patterns - they will find some of them, and
they will miss identifying tons of them, miss them all together
etc. Those EW programs I've looked at, they all constantly change
their counts as well - ha kind of like a lot of Elliot Wavers
do
Brophy, I used Advanced Get
This is from a fellow trader I follow. I've used ...
Posted by bulf6285 on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 01:37 pm
Brophy, I used Advanced Get for years when I was trading on the floor of the Comex. The MOBs were incredibly accurate. Their Elliot Wave count was also pretty good. Never been able to replicate the MOB in Tradestation, and I have tried very hard :) Can't find a good enough explanation of the indicator to work off of though. I'd be happy to do the programming and share if anyone has the parameters.
Yes, I've used Advanced Get
Posted by brophy on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 03:34 pm
Yes, I've used Advanced Get from time to time over the years. Creator was Tom Joseph who has created many excellent indicators. (He has his own company now and most recently created many of the same tools for VectorVest programs. I mean almost exactly the same tools and calls them different names! ha!!) The best explanation of it that I heard was a combination of a Fib extension and Gann. However, his Advanced Get's Elliot Wave left me cold though. Have no idea how you would recreate it. If you purchased it, then you own it forever and you can use any number of charting services.
there's versions on Trading View
Posted by matt on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 03:51 pm
there's versions on Trading View on Elliot Wave indicators like that, one of them I have is called Elliot Wave Absolute, it's okay, But I don't use it to make decisions, more just fun to look at once in a while
but guys, view them out of curiosity, I won't put too much energy into them. Focus on price action, patterns, and a few indicators that you might use.
the guys who are always looking for that next holy grail indicator never settle on something and master it, and thus end up never making any money.
plus if you think about - there's nothing magical about those programs trying to generate EW signals. They use technical indicators to try and have it guess what the pattern is - which will never ever be as good as you doing it yourself. It's just like those programs that try to identify stock patterns like coils, flags, inverse H&S patterns - they will find some of them, and they will miss identifying tons of them, miss them all together etc. Those EW programs I've looked at, they all constantly change their counts as well - ha kind of like a lot of Elliot Wavers do
A funny thing about those
Posted by brophy on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 04:04 pm
A funny thing about those auto Elliot Waves. They always work. Until you put money behind them.
Posted by timebandit on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 04:14 pm
Posted by DigiNomad on 22nd of Sep 2022 at 03:52 pm