rogerv and
others-you need a membership to Stockcharts to see
the intra day chart links. Many folks here have memberships
and that's why we post the dynamic links. Some don't that's
why we post snapshots, but honestly a membership to Stockcharts can
be a benefit since you can then use the charts
Posted by newgeorge on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:19 pm
Matt - those of us looking for an investment service aren't
looking for a "data-only" service where we have to spend as
many hours shifting the data as you do when you put it
toghether!
I understand see the time you put in and it looks worth the
money
except in that there is a regular lack of bottom line info
that can be used in real time by more lonfg term investors.
Seems like you all hedge you bets pretty good and there is a lot
of after the fact we told you so's. Many times Steve just takes
both sides of the market and then says "we'll let the market
decide"... and then you guys do day trades using systems.
I for one can't day trade. I need more consistent analysis that
actually frees me from having to update my own charts, etc...
Also the BLOG during the day is for short term analysis.
If you are a position trader, then you should not be concerned with
intra day market commentary on the BLOG
Our Watch List and Intra Day updates and Newsetters are geared
toward intermediate analysis and that's what you should focus
on.
We have been looking for a counter trend rally for a while and
that's what this is. You have only been here since Dec
31st.
I gotta say -- this really isn't an investment service.
Even using the watchlist, you often have to decide for yourself
what your risk tolerence is, where your stops will be, how much to
exit at the targets, etc. This site is great for people who
want to learn something about technical analysis, whether for
sawing trades or daytrading. If you don't want to do that
work of learning, someplace like gorilla trades or something would
be best -- where you are given exact entry points and stops and
sell points.
newgeorge- we have day traders and we have swing traders and we have
long term traders.
If you are a day trader, then of course you need the ability to
view intra day charts! If you are not a day trader then don't
worry about them. My comments were directed toward day
traders who want to see intra day charts.
Obviously the comment about stockcharts membership was not
directed at you; only folks what want to view the charts intra
day.
Trade the Watch List if you are a swing trader, don't worry
about 5 min charts if you are a swing trader. Now as far as
postion trader? Well this is not the kind of market to
position into for long term traders! This bear market is far
from over and this is a counter trend rally
Newsletter
Subscribe to our email list for regular free market updates
as well as a chance to get coupons!
15 Min Chart
Posted by rogerv on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:02 pm
The 15 Min chart in the Sticky comes out as a daily chart, or I have real problems with my computer. What do you see when you click on it ?
Yes - that's why I
Posted by newgeorge on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:12 pm
Yes - that's why I asked for the udated because unless you have a premium membership with stockcharts the posted charts on the blog don't UPDATE!
rogerv and others-you need a membership
Posted by matt on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:11 pm
rogerv and others-you need a membership to Stockcharts to see the intra day chart links. Many folks here have memberships and that's why we post the dynamic links. Some don't that's why we post snapshots, but honestly a membership to Stockcharts can be a benefit since you can then use the charts
Matt - those of us
Posted by newgeorge on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:19 pm
Matt - those of us looking for an investment service aren't looking for a "data-only" service where we have to spend as many hours shifting the data as you do when you put it toghether!
I understand see the time you put in and it looks worth the money except in that there is a regular lack of bottom line info that can be used in real time by more lonfg term investors.
Seems like you all hedge you bets pretty good and there is a lot of after the fact we told you so's. Many times Steve just takes both sides of the market and then says "we'll let the market decide"... and then you guys do day trades using systems.
I for one can't day trade. I need more consistent analysis that actually frees me from having to update my own charts, etc...
Also the BLOG during the
Posted by matt on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:29 pm
Also the BLOG during the day is for short term analysis. If you are a position trader, then you should not be concerned with intra day market commentary on the BLOG
Our Watch List and Intra Day updates and Newsetters are geared toward intermediate analysis and that's what you should focus on.
We have been looking for a counter trend rally for a while and that's what this is. You have only been here since Dec 31st.
newgeorge
Posted by Michael on 5th of Jan 2009 at 05:47 pm
I gotta say -- this really isn't an investment service. Even using the watchlist, you often have to decide for yourself what your risk tolerence is, where your stops will be, how much to exit at the targets, etc. This site is great for people who want to learn something about technical analysis, whether for sawing trades or daytrading. If you don't want to do that work of learning, someplace like gorilla trades or something would be best -- where you are given exact entry points and stops and sell points.
I don't think what your
Posted by dylan398 on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:25 pm
I don't think what your looking for exists....it sounds like you someone to tell you what to buy and when to buy it....
Newgeorge - there are plenty
Posted by dodgerdog on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:24 pm
Newgeorge - there are plenty of ideas for traders on the Watchlist - did you play them the past two weeks
newgeorge - we have day traders
Posted by matt on 5th of Jan 2009 at 03:21 pm
newgeorge - we have day traders and we have swing traders and we have long term traders.
If you are a day trader, then of course you need the ability to view intra day charts! If you are not a day trader then don't worry about them. My comments were directed toward day traders who want to see intra day charts.
Obviously the comment about stockcharts membership was not directed at you; only folks what want to view the charts intra day.
Trade the Watch List if you are a swing trader, don't worry about 5 min charts if you are a swing trader. Now as far as postion trader? Well this is not the kind of market to position into for long term traders! This bear market is far from over and this is a counter trend rally