Beware of Stockcharts SPY historical data !!!

    Posted by dougmil on 5th of May 2011 at 07:32 pm

    I wrote this in response to a question ealier this afternoon from Susan about SPY quotation data:

    Susan,


    Beware of SPY (or any equity that issues dividends and cap gains), including stocks. I think it is generally fine for intraday charts, however Stcokcharts is one of the few (I can't find another) that adjusts past prices not just for splits (they all do that) but also for dividends and cap gains distributions!

    You can verify this by checking some major top or bottom in the past on another charting service and comparing to Stockcharts. They are different! Stockcharts historical data is artificially adjusted downward.

    What does it mean? Stockcharts is fabulous for comparing long term total returns because it includes dividends. Good for buy and hold investors and value investors. However, for short term traders, you can't pinpoint old gaps, tops and bottoms that may come into play.

    It is generally fine for intraday charts as they usually do the adjustments for dividends and cap gains once a quarter. Know when SPY is adjusted so this doesn't throw you a head scrathing curveball the day after.

    I discussed this with the owner of Stockcharts, Chip Anderson, a couple months ago when he spoke at our monthly cycles meeting in Buena Park, CA and he confirmed what I just said. There is info about it on stoccharts if you snoop around.

     

    Doug Milliken

    I used Yahoo and BigCharts

    Posted by stevedfw on 5th of May 2011 at 08:20 pm

    I used Yahoo and BigCharts historical data. On Yahoo, it shows the actual close and adjusted close for dividend and splits. I compared Big Charts data to Yahoo and it looks like Big Charts using actual close.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our email list for regular free market updates
as well as a chance to get coupons!