To Nayan Shah - anyone who says they understand the stock market very well provides substantial evidence that they are a self-deluded amateur. If you were a true student of the market, like you say you are, you should have known when to exit a trade (regardless of what you think a newsletter says). This newsletter has provided a wealth of knowledge over the years. You should thank them rather than criticize them. But if you were a true student of the game, you would have known that.

Good luck to you, Gary M

Although I am an experienced trader, I would not mind a bit of hand holding from a trader like you that I trust. One comment that I read suggested the hand holding would limit learning by those having their hands held. I don't think so. Having  good trader sharing knowledge of how they think and trade can always be a learning experience IMO. I wish I had that opportunity earlier!

If I may add . . . what I try to discern from your verbal cues on recommended trades is which trades you favor from that day's list. I can pick up cues from your verbal descriptions and that helps me prioritize your recommended trades. I find value in these details. So, my idea of valuable "hand holding" would be almost a rank-ordering of the top 3 recommended trades, perhaps, more so than where and when to pull the trigger on each trade. Just sayin'.

Thank you for your interest and efforts in always adding to the value of your service! We all benefit from you sharing your knowledge.

Hello Matt - Thanks very much for the heads-up on the CAKE weekly!! 

It always saddens me to hear of reports like yours where  trader has busted out. We have all been there in our own personal circumstance. However, I have to say that if you lost it all WHILE subscribing to this website you should not be trading at all. This site will not tell you what to do, but  they will provide you with valuable information you will need to make your own informed decision on what to buy and when, and what to sell and when. I now trade for a living and it has taken me 30 years to get to this place. I can tell you that there is no better service that you can subscribe to - NONE. These guys do more hard work than any service I know, and I have tried most of them. Prove to yourself that the information they provide has value. I challenge you to do nothing but track their trade ideas for one month. Follow them. Categorize their ideas: bullish, bearish, pennants, breakouts, penny stocks, big boys, commodities. Why not even track Matt vs Steve within these categories? Do some research. Find out for yourself how good or how bad they are. 

What I value the most is the shear number of charts they provide. These guys are the best. Best of luck to you. Be humble. Be smart.

Matt, I don't understand how anyone can criticize this website that you have developed. This is the best we traders have available to us. Thank you! Please tell Victorh he needs an attitude adjustment.