Gold commercial net short

Posted by matt on 13th of Dec 2013 at 03:47 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - I figured I would beat rbreesethis week and post the COT on gold before him LOL

anyway the commercial net short increased to 28K from 23K last week

actually the commercial net short was 28K last week, I'm sure it's dipped way down, the 52K was from the previous week.

However here's an interesting point that I've mentioned probably a year ago: what happens when it goes negative and flips?  

I've stated this before, I've checked the COT data before the 2001 bottom and it was flipped - my point is, that could be confirmation of a bear market - as the commercial net short was not 'net short' during the last gold bear market but net positve

Here's graphic that I put together to show what I mean, I took the COT showing the 'Net Short' form the 2004 bottom, the 2008 bottom, and this year, in the past the net short has always increased when gold has come off the lows, howeverthis time it has been decreasing, odd....

Please note:when you click on the attached graphic, it will appear small because of the light box effect' therefore click on the 'open in new tab' at the bottom left to open it up in a separate browser window, you can then click on it again to expand it to full size.

Here's another URL

http://news.goldseek.com/COT/

the mos recent commercial net short is now 95K, while this is quite low, it confuses me because in the past the number has always increased when the price of gold moves up.  For example on  the prior week on Tues April 23rd the 'Net Short' was 104K when the price of gold was $1413 an ounce, and last Tues April 30th the Net Short fell to 95K even though the price of gold moved up to 1476.

Years ago I remember looking at the 'Net Short' before the gold bull market began in 2001 and I recall that the 'Net Short' was inverted, it was always negative while the 'Net Long' was always positive - in other words completely inverted to what it has been since 2001.   We'll have to monitor this over time.

If anyone has a URL to previous or historical data prior to 2001 let me know or a chart.  

here's graphic that I put together to show what I mean, I took the COT showing the 'Net Short' form the 2004 bottom, the 2008 bottom, and this year, in the past the net short has always increased when gold has come off the lows, however this time it has been decreasing, odd....

I used to have an

shorts

Posted by matt on 3rd of May 2013 at 09:18 am

I used to have an account with Scottrade back in the 90's and early 2000's and they were awful.  I opened an IB account I think back in 2000 or 2001

Commercial net short

Posted by matt on 12th of Apr 2013 at 04:03 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - no change today, HOWEVER remember guys this COT data is delayed and as of Tuesday's closing prices, it does not reflect the declines on Wed, Thur, and of course the bloodbath today, we won't know the effect of today's action on the COT data until next Friday

Commercial Net short for gold

Posted by matt on 1st of Mar 2013 at 03:47 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - the COT data is out and the commercial net short for gold is 138K - remember this number is as of Tuesday as it's always 3 days delayed.

Gold Commercial Net Short update

Posted by matt on 23rd of Feb 2013 at 02:38 am

$GOLD - Chart Link - as expected the 'Commercial Net Short' dropped quite a bit on gold to 132K down from 161K last week.  However remember that the COT data is delayed by 3 days (reported on Friday afternoons but is actually Tuesday's numbers), therefore Friday's COT report does not include the big drop on Wed etc, thus in reality the true 'net short' number is probably below 130K.  

It's nice to see this number coming down, boy I'd love to see it below 100K, but not sure if we'll see that at this time...

remember the wave count I

GDX RSI 2 quite oversold now

Posted by matt on 20th of Feb 2013 at 02:51 pm

remember the wave count I showed on the weekend - I think if a bounce does come, at best it will only be wave B of the complex pattern for form a lower high, then will sell off again in the summer.

The 2nd chart shows the commercial net short - it will be fun to see what that number is this week!  However the problem is that this number will only reflect Tuesday's closing prices and won't reflect today's move since the COT data is delayed by 3 days.

the third chart shows the monthly chart of gold with the long term trendlines - as you my thought has been that we would eventually test at least one of these uptrend lines - also watch that 14 RSI and the 50% level, that has been super important for gold since 2001

Gold commercial Net Short

Posted by matt on 15th of Feb 2013 at 03:53 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - The COT data is out and the commercial 'Net Short' for gold is 161K, down from 174K last week.  

Again remember that this number is as of Tuesday, thus since gold has dropped every day this week, Wed, Thur, and Today big time, the Net Short is likely lower than this, perhaps it's 150 or high 140ks?  just a guess, again it's always delayed by 3 days.

I would LOVE to see it go down to the lower 100K range even below 100K, that would mark a super bottom IMO like the past, every time it fell below 100K, it marked bottoms - but of course that hasn't happens since 2008 and the 'low market' has steadily risen over the years if you look at the past data

have a nice weekend, LONG weekend!!!!

ha - yeah well first

Gold Commercial Net Short

Posted by matt on 15th of Feb 2013 at 10:19 am

ha - yeah well first off gold is gonna go wherever it wants to go - the 1527, that's a pretty specific number.  However there is a support range from 1535 - 1527, which is the horizontal support of a large descending triangle pattern - the 1527 is the lowest part of the horizontal line in my pattern - I've been showing this chart since early last year so that 1530 ish area is no surprise to anyone.  Honestly I would not be so specific about 1527, I would call a support range-  let's just say 1525 - 1535 vs a specific price.

Now - my problem is that if gold does go all the way back to that area to me it would not be good, that is more of a bearish pattern and that area has been tested now 3 times - my thoughts are that if gold does go down and test that area again that the support area will not hold and we'll be looking at a much deeper correction.  The pattern measures about 275 points, which would take gold down to a target of $1250!

And longer term I think we will probably see gold at least test one of my long term uptrend lines on this monthly chart (the second chart)

otherwise regardless, I'm not gonna hold out for a specific price to be met - I'll react and adjust to the charts as they develop.  I'll also monitor the COT data and if the Net Short falls below 100K, that would mark a significant bottom IMO.

Gold Commercial Net Short

Posted by matt on 15th of Feb 2013 at 10:06 am

$GOLD - Chart Link - It will be interesting to see what the Com Net Short is for gold this afternoon, it's reported about 15 min before the close.

I expect to see a drop - HOWEVER gold has been down every day since Tuesday and the COT data is delayed and only shows what the COT data was on Tuesday, so it won't reflect the weakness from Wed - today.  Therefore whatever the number is, in reality it will be lower.  

However that said - this Net Short moves slowly and so I don't expect a huge drop.  

I talked about this on Monday a bit, I wouldn't be surprised to see the Net Short ultimately work it's way down the the lower 100K, which will take some time and price decline - fine by me though

GDX and gold

Posted by matt on 13th of Feb 2013 at 01:44 pm

GDX - Chart Link - GDX and gold of course continue to be dogs.  GDX continues to find resistance at its 9 day EMA. 

GDX - Chart Link - 60 min view

GLD - Chart Link - daily view of GLD

It will be interesting to see what the commercial net short on Gold is this Friday after the COT data is reported in the afternoon

Gold commercial net short update

Posted by matt on 28th of Dec 2012 at 03:59 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - Just got the COT data, the Commercial Net short fell to 188K, it was 202K last week, so it's nice to see it come down even further.  Again it was quite a bit lower in May when it hit 130K, but it's nice to see it working lower

Gold commercial net short

Posted by matt on 28th of Dec 2012 at 02:32 pm

$GOLD - Chart Link - later today before the close, the COT data will be released, I'm curious to see if the commercial net short has now fallen below 200K

GDX comments

Posted by matt on 28th of Dec 2012 at 02:30 pm

GDX - Chart Link - 60 min view, it was up slightly in the morning but has weakened, of course logically it was stopped yesterday at the downtrend line on the 60 min chart.  As I said, now the question is, will it make a higher low or a lower low?  See how I have it drawn. 

GDX - Chart Link - another 60 min option - wedge forming perhaps, a lower low could still be part of the wedge

GDX - Chart Link - daily - of course never broken the downtrend line and stopped at the 20 MA yesterday so nothing technically has changed yet.  The best hope for the 'bulls' is for a wedge to form here inside the channel

Obviously the Fiscal Cliff will have an effect, gold really needs the gov to continue to spend and print money - it might not like austerity so much.

later today on gold the COT data will be released, I'm curious to see if the commercial net short has now fallen below 200K

I haven't been following the

Gold commercial net short

Posted by matt on 24th of Dec 2012 at 10:09 am

I haven't been following the COT option data, so I don't know what a good number is, to really have a good feel for that you have to plot it with the price of gold for years and compare the numbers to peaks and troughs in gold, however I've been following the commercial net short for many years and therefore I have a feel for it.  First thing to realize, the commercials are ALWAYS's net short, so that's not the issue, the issue is with how much they are net short.  When the Net Short is > 250K, gold is toppy, though it can stay elevated for long periods of time. When it falls below 200K and into the 100's, that's generally a positive. If you look at the chart, major bottoms used to occur when this 'net short' fell below 100K, however this low threshold number has steadily risen over the years and the commercial short net low after 2008 has been in the 100's, the last two lows it was 165K and 130K.

caddpro123- I mostly follow just the charts, I look at the commercial COT trader data from time to time, however the volume you talk about is interesting and creates a big supply - question:  you mentioned the last 4 times, do you have those dates and numbers or a chart showing that?  If not the dates will suffice, thx

net short now??  That makes no sense to me, the commercials are always net short, they are never net long - that's why I call it, the 'gold commercial net short'.  I have never seen the commercials long in over 10 years since I've followed that.   You have to look at how net short are they.  Last week they were 269K contracts net short, week prior was 262K.  To me it's better for bottoms when it falls into the lower 100Ks not so good for tops

http://news.goldseek.com/COT/

here's my weekly chart showing the commercial net short at various major tops and bottoms

yep rbreesefor sure.  now I have not been following the commercials for the SPX index, generally I find those hit or miss, however in order for me to get a feeling for it, I like to be following it and I have not.  Gold futures COT data I do follow and so it will be interesting to see what those are. 

Newsletter

Subscribe to our email list for regular free market updates
as well as a chance to get coupons!