Posted by whistlebear on 7th of Aug 2009 at 07:49 pm
Broken Windows Everywhere
These days, you can’t pick up a paper, turn on the TV, or surf
the Internet without being bombarded by economic fallacies --
gaping holes in logic that not only go uncontested by the masses
but are absorbed and regurgitated by them.
Take this gem of a headline and lead-in written by a “senior
writer” for CNNMoney.com yesterday:
Cash for Clunkers: Real stimulus
The boost to auto sales caused by the government trade-in
program should lead to increased production from Detroit. That
would have a big ripple effect.
Here we see by far the most common of all economic fallacies –
the fallacy from which many others stem. It is the fallacy of
overlooking secondary consequences, also known as “The Broken
Window Fallacy.”
To quote Henry Hazlitt’s
Economics in One Lesson:
Let us begin with the simplest illustration possible: let us,
emulating Bastiat, choose a broken pane of glass.
A young hoodlum, say, heaves a brick through the window of a
baker's shop. The shopkeeper runs out furious, but the boy is gone.
A crowd gathers, and begins to stare with quiet satisfaction at the
gaping hole in the window and the shattered glass over the bread
and pies. After a while the crowd feels the need for philosophic
reflection. And several of its members are almost certain to remind
each other or the baker that, after all, the misfortune has its
bright side. It will make business for some glazier. As they begin
to think of this they elaborate upon it. How much does a new plate
glass window cost? Fifty dollars? That will be quite a sum. After
all, if windows were never broken, what would happen to the glass
business? Then, of course, the thing is endless. The glazier will
have $50 more to spend with other merchants, and these in turn will
have $50 more to spend with still other merchants, and so ad
infinitum. The smashed window will go on providing money and
employment in ever-widening circles. The logical conclusion from
all this would be, if the crowd drew it, that the little hoodlum
who threw the brick, far from being a public menace, was a public
benefactor.
Now let us take another look. The crowd is at least right in its
first conclusion. This little act of vandalism will in the first
instance mean more business for some glazier. The glazier will be
no more unhappy to learn of the incident than an undertaker to
learn of a death. But the shopkeeper will be out $50 that he was
planning to spend for a new suit. Because he has had to replace a
window, he will have to go without the suit (or some equivalent
need or luxury). Instead of having a window and $50 he now has
merely a window. Or, as he was planning to buy the suit that very
afternoon, instead of having both a window and a suit he must be
content with the window and no suit. If we think of him as a part
of the community, the community has lost a new suit that might
otherwise have come into being, and is just that much poorer.
The glazier's gain of business, in short, is merely the tailor's
loss of business. No new "employment" has been added. The people in
the crowd were thinking only of two parties to the transaction, the
baker and the glazier. They had forgotten the potential third party
involved, the tailor. They forgot him precisely because he will not
now enter the scene. They will see the new window in the next day
or two. They will never see the extra suit, precisely because it
will never be made. They see only what is immediately visible to
the eye.
So it is with the aforementioned “Cash for Clunkers” program.
What is seen is people trading in old cars and buying new ones.
What is unseen is the lost business that will never take place
because wealth has been transferred from taxpayers to car buyers.
The money taken from taxpayers can’t be used for other things.
As an aside, I want to point out how appropriate the title to
this piece is. You see, the “Cash for Clunkers” program requires
that trade-ins be scrapped – literally breaking windows
everywhere.
You forgot to mention the dentist who fixes the mechanic's
teeth and the dentist's children who need tuition for private
school, and the school teacher who needs........ Maybe what you are
saying is that things are related........thanks
not to mention, its just leveraging debt all over
again.............the government is borrowing money to give people
money to encourage them to norrow more money to buy new cars.
as we all know, older cars require more "fix-ups" and that
business will now be lost forever on the "clunkers", i.e.,
mechanics, fender repairs, spare parts, etc.
Cash for Clunkers - what most people forget to think about!
Posted by whistlebear on 7th of Aug 2009 at 07:49 pm
Broken Windows Everywhere
These days, you can’t pick up a paper, turn on the TV, or surf the Internet without being bombarded by economic fallacies -- gaping holes in logic that not only go uncontested by the masses but are absorbed and regurgitated by them.
Take this gem of a headline and lead-in written by a “senior writer” for CNNMoney.com yesterday:
Cash for Clunkers: Real stimulus
The boost to auto sales caused by the government trade-in program should lead to increased production from Detroit. That would have a big ripple effect.
Here we see by far the most common of all economic fallacies – the fallacy from which many others stem. It is the fallacy of overlooking secondary consequences, also known as “The Broken Window Fallacy.”
To quote Henry Hazlitt’s Economics in One Lesson:
Let us begin with the simplest illustration possible: let us, emulating Bastiat, choose a broken pane of glass.
A young hoodlum, say, heaves a brick through the window of a baker's shop. The shopkeeper runs out furious, but the boy is gone. A crowd gathers, and begins to stare with quiet satisfaction at the gaping hole in the window and the shattered glass over the bread and pies. After a while the crowd feels the need for philosophic reflection. And several of its members are almost certain to remind each other or the baker that, after all, the misfortune has its bright side. It will make business for some glazier. As they begin to think of this they elaborate upon it. How much does a new plate glass window cost? Fifty dollars? That will be quite a sum. After all, if windows were never broken, what would happen to the glass business? Then, of course, the thing is endless. The glazier will have $50 more to spend with other merchants, and these in turn will have $50 more to spend with still other merchants, and so ad infinitum. The smashed window will go on providing money and employment in ever-widening circles. The logical conclusion from all this would be, if the crowd drew it, that the little hoodlum who threw the brick, far from being a public menace, was a public benefactor.
Now let us take another look. The crowd is at least right in its first conclusion. This little act of vandalism will in the first instance mean more business for some glazier. The glazier will be no more unhappy to learn of the incident than an undertaker to learn of a death. But the shopkeeper will be out $50 that he was planning to spend for a new suit. Because he has had to replace a window, he will have to go without the suit (or some equivalent need or luxury). Instead of having a window and $50 he now has merely a window. Or, as he was planning to buy the suit that very afternoon, instead of having both a window and a suit he must be content with the window and no suit. If we think of him as a part of the community, the community has lost a new suit that might otherwise have come into being, and is just that much poorer.
The glazier's gain of business, in short, is merely the tailor's loss of business. No new "employment" has been added. The people in the crowd were thinking only of two parties to the transaction, the baker and the glazier. They had forgotten the potential third party involved, the tailor. They forgot him precisely because he will not now enter the scene. They will see the new window in the next day or two. They will never see the extra suit, precisely because it will never be made. They see only what is immediately visible to the eye.
So it is with the aforementioned “Cash for Clunkers” program. What is seen is people trading in old cars and buying new ones. What is unseen is the lost business that will never take place because wealth has been transferred from taxpayers to car buyers. The money taken from taxpayers can’t be used for other things.
As an aside, I want to point out how appropriate the title to this piece is. You see, the “Cash for Clunkers” program requires that trade-ins be scrapped – literally breaking windows everywhere.
Title: Theory of Relativity ???? You
Posted by captmet on 8th of Aug 2009 at 12:24 pm
not to mention, its just
Posted by Michael on 7th of Aug 2009 at 09:00 pm
not to mention, its just leveraging debt all over again.............the government is borrowing money to give people money to encourage them to norrow more money to buy new cars.
repair business
Posted by rjay on 7th of Aug 2009 at 08:59 pm
as we all know, older cars require more "fix-ups" and that business will now be lost forever on the "clunkers", i.e., mechanics, fender repairs, spare parts, etc.
good article, thanks.
Posted by Michael on 7th of Aug 2009 at 08:57 pm
good article, thanks.