a_l_ - No, it's commercials only. I
don't care what the large speculators are doing, tells you exactly
the same thing just in mirror opposite, I simply subtract the
commercial long from short. Large Speculators get more long
as price goes higher while commercials add to their shorts, the
reverse is true when gold falls, large speculators decrease their
longs while commercials increase them
here's the COT data I use, I only subtract the commercial long
from short. I know what you are saying that non commercials
are a larger market, however I don't really care, I think you get
the same conclusions regardless. I also don't care about the
options.
I've been tracking that since 2002, it used to be quite useful
when gold was in a bull market from 2001 - 2011, especially prior
to 2009, every time the commercial net short fell below 100K, you
went long, was like clockwork.
Got it. You referenced a 30K delta, which was a figure 1/3
higher than the commerical only WoW. I thought you were combining
them.
I agree on the relevance at extremes and have written so
repeatedly.
I agree that at extremes specs & hedgers tell you the same
thing.
In between, however, on short-term direction - which is what
people seem to want to get from these numbers - specs will tell you
more because they're the ones with risk at stake. Hedgers lock
things in and keep on running their businesses. They don't get
caught short only to cover high and they don't get trapped long
only to sell low. Hedge funds do this all the time.
I also agree on these numbers being secondary at best in terms
of trades. If you study how good the specs are at riding trends
over time in each instrument & how sensitive the
producers/consumers are to price over time, they can be supporting
evidence for a position. But price patterns and specific triggers
are primary.
I only started writing on this topic because I wanted to
understand it better and saw so much written that was either
irrelevant to trading or outright misinformation.
As they say in The Giver, 'Precision of Language'. I want to
understand the market mechanisms well, describe them precisely and
use them to my advantage. I have found most COT commentary and all
PM conspiracy theories worthless.
Here you go. The problem with including the swap dealers is that
their counterparties are typically specs (and when they're the
other side of spec trades they are usually neutralizing their risk
like a floor broker would). I like to see just the commercials
& specs on their own and track the rate of change and the
extremes in their positioning.
Robert...please post a screenshot of the report you're referring
to - your numbers do not match up with the disaggregated reports
(whether you take options into account or not).
Newsletter
Subscribe to our email list for regular free market updates
as well as a chance to get coupons!
Gold Commercials reduced shorts by about 20k contracts but SILVER virtually NO change.
Posted by rbreese on 29th of May 2015 at 03:47 pm
My airlines are perking up
Posted by rbreese on 29th of May 2015 at 04:31 pm
My airlines are perking up too. Great weekend.Both coasts need rain BADLY.
Actually it was 21k and
Posted by rbreese on 29th of May 2015 at 04:27 pm
Actually it was 21k and I sent shot to you direct.
That report includes swaps dealers
Posted by a_l_ on 29th of May 2015 at 04:34 pm
That report includes swaps dealers - look at the disaggregated for the change just in producer & consumer positions.
Would you show me the
Posted by rbreese on 29th of May 2015 at 04:42 pm
Would you show me the disaggregated numbers as you are the first to point this out. I am sure you are correct but send me the screen shot. THX
The last screenshot was futures
Posted by a_l_ on 29th of May 2015 at 04:53 pm
The last screenshot was futures only. Here's futures & options together, which is what makes more sense to me to watch.
The new Commercial Net short
Posted by matt on 29th of May 2015 at 05:37 pm
The new Commercial Net short is 100K, a drop from 132 last week. The low 4 weeks ago was 74K, here's a history chart.
Matt - to be clear
Posted by a_l_ on 29th of May 2015 at 07:39 pm
Matt - to be clear that's Commercial & Non-Commercial combined. Fair enough if that's what you've tracked over the years.
a_l_ - No, it's commercials only.
Posted by matt on 30th of May 2015 at 09:18 pm
a_l_ - No, it's commercials only. I don't care what the large speculators are doing, tells you exactly the same thing just in mirror opposite, I simply subtract the commercial long from short. Large Speculators get more long as price goes higher while commercials add to their shorts, the reverse is true when gold falls, large speculators decrease their longs while commercials increase them
here's the COT data I use, I only subtract the commercial long from short. I know what you are saying that non commercials are a larger market, however I don't really care, I think you get the same conclusions regardless. I also don't care about the options.
I've been tracking that since 2002, it used to be quite useful when gold was in a bull market from 2001 - 2011, especially prior to 2009, every time the commercial net short fell below 100K, you went long, was like clockwork.
http://www.cftc.gov/dea/futures/deacmxsf.htm
Got it. You referenced a
Posted by a_l_ on 31st of May 2015 at 12:22 pm
Got it. You referenced a 30K delta, which was a figure 1/3 higher than the commerical only WoW. I thought you were combining them.
I agree on the relevance at extremes and have written so repeatedly.
I agree that at extremes specs & hedgers tell you the same thing.
In between, however, on short-term direction - which is what people seem to want to get from these numbers - specs will tell you more because they're the ones with risk at stake. Hedgers lock things in and keep on running their businesses. They don't get caught short only to cover high and they don't get trapped long only to sell low. Hedge funds do this all the time.
I also agree on these
Posted by a_l_ on 31st of May 2015 at 12:39 pm
I also agree on these numbers being secondary at best in terms of trades. If you study how good the specs are at riding trends over time in each instrument & how sensitive the producers/consumers are to price over time, they can be supporting evidence for a position. But price patterns and specific triggers are primary.
I only started writing on this topic because I wanted to understand it better and saw so much written that was either irrelevant to trading or outright misinformation.
As they say in The Giver, 'Precision of Language'. I want to understand the market mechanisms well, describe them precisely and use them to my advantage. I have found most COT commentary and all PM conspiracy theories worthless.
Here you go. The problem
Posted by a_l_ on 29th of May 2015 at 04:51 pm
Here you go. The problem with including the swap dealers is that their counterparties are typically specs (and when they're the other side of spec trades they are usually neutralizing their risk like a floor broker would). I like to see just the commercials & specs on their own and track the rate of change and the extremes in their positioning.
Robert...please post a screenshot of
Posted by a_l_ on 29th of May 2015 at 04:08 pm
Robert...please post a screenshot of the report you're referring to - your numbers do not match up with the disaggregated reports (whether you take options into account or not).