I
don't know but in spite of having 22+ technical systems,
studying & analyzing zillion plus charts, you never
even got a hint of the massive downside move of a whopping 160+
handles in S&P coming. Not only that,
you were bullish before the downside move started and that
you initiated 2 more bullish positions during this downside
move. I don't think I will ever subscribe to your
newsletter again after my subscription expires. Better yet, you can
refund my remainder of 6 month subscription. I have been in the
market for about 20+ years and have gone through and traded 2 stock
market crashes. So I do understand stock market very well. Thank
You.
Regards,
Nayan Shah
Reply: Do NOT confuse the SPY System with our Newsletter
Analysis of the Markets. Your previous comments in September
indicated some confusion and Matt responded and said to avoid
trading this system WITHOUT a clear understanding. We
acknowledge that the system trade has led to draw-downs (it has
several times in the past as well) and that's why one must accept
the system or avoid trading it but our analysis was far from
bullish which you would have recognized if you took time to listen
to all the newsletters.
The SPX Wedge was drawn and shown multiple times PRIOR to the
decline. Also you clearly didn't listen to my comments about
the VIX Weekly BB's contracting and expecting a larger move over
time.
what are you talking about? If the system triggered a sell
signal, why did the system not sell during market hours and inform
us. Even after close, the system still could have sold the SPY and
gone cash and informed us. Then we can use the signal from
the second system to sell short SPY. Why it has to be
complicated? Basically this tells me the system did not
sell although it triggered a sell signal when it should have and
the same time should have informed the clients.
The community is delayed by three days for non registered users.
I don't know but in spite
Posted by nayan32 on 13th of Oct 2018 at 03:07 am
I don't know but in spite of having 22+ technical systems, studying & analyzing zillion plus charts, you never even got a hint of the massive downside move of a whopping 160+ handles in S&P coming. Not only that , you were bullish before the downside move started and that you initiated 2 more bullish positions during this downside move. I don't think I will ever subscribe to your newsletter again after my subscription expires. Better yet, you can refund my remainder of 6 month subscription. I have been in the market for about 20+ years and have gone through and traded 2 stock market crashes. So I do understand stock market very well. Thank You.
Regards,
Nayan Shah
Reply: Do NOT confuse the SPY System with our Newsletter Analysis of the Markets. Your previous comments in September indicated some confusion and Matt responded and said to avoid trading this system WITHOUT a clear understanding. We acknowledge that the system trade has led to draw-downs (it has several times in the past as well) and that's why one must accept the system or avoid trading it but our analysis was far from bullish which you would have recognized if you took time to listen to all the newsletters.
The SPX Wedge was drawn and shown multiple times PRIOR to the decline. Also you clearly didn't listen to my comments about the VIX Weekly BB's contracting and expecting a larger move over time.
https://stockcharts.com/h-sc/ui?s=$SPX&p=D&yr=0&mn=9&dy=15&id=p47716059604&a=592740180&listNum=61
what are you talking about?
i assume the SPY system did NOT exit?
Posted by nayan32 on 17th of Sep 2018 at 04:47 pm
what are you talking about? If the system triggered a sell signal, why did the system not sell during market hours and inform us. Even after close, the system still could have sold the SPY and gone cash and informed us. Then we can use the signal from the second system to sell short SPY. Why it has to be complicated? Basically this tells me the system did not sell although it triggered a sell signal when it should have and the same time should have informed the clients.
Hello, Is there any update on
Tuesday Newsletter
Posted by nayan32 on 1st of Aug 2018 at 04:55 am
Hello,
Is there any update on this trade ?
"System entered long position in SPY at $279.90 on Mon, Jul 30."
Regards,
Nayan Shah